Does AI Search Optimization Replace Traditional SEO?
SEO has been the backbone of digital marketing for decades, helping businesses rank higher in search results and drive organic traffic. But with the rise of AI-powered search engines like ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini, and Bing’s AI chat, many marketers are asking: Does AI search optimization replace traditional SEO?
The short answer: No – but it does fundamentally changes the game from what we've used to. Traditional SEO remains important, but businesses need to now adapt their strategies to also optimize for AI-generated search results through Generative Engine Optimization (GEO). In other words, SEO isn’t going away, but it has a new AI-powered sidekick that demands attention. Forward-thinking marketers are treating AI search as another channel for growth rather than a replacement for Google.
“Think AI Search as just a new channel where you can start driving growth.” – Hannes Jersenius, Growth Lead of Superlines
In this article, I'll break down the key differences between traditional SEO and AI search optimization, and how businesses should approach both to maximize their visibility.
1. How Traditional SEO Works
Traditional search engines like Google and Bing rely on algorithms to crawl, index, and rank web pages based on several factors:
•Keywords and Search Intent – Matching page content to the terms and intent users search for.
•Backlinks and Domain Authority – Prioritizing content from trusted sources (quality and quantity of other sites linking to you).
•On-Page SEO Factors – Optimizing titles, meta descriptions, headings, and using structured data (schema) to help search engines understand your content.
•User Engagement Metrics – Measuring how users interact (click-through rates, bounce rates, time on site) as signals of content quality.
Businesses have refined these tactics to climb the Search Engine Results Pages (SERPs) and attract organic traffic. Traditional SEO is about getting to the top of Google’s results. But AI-powered search doesn’t work the same way.
2. How AI Search Engines Are Changing SEO
Unlike traditional search engines, AI-powered search models (like large language models, or LLMs) don’t simply return a list of ranked links – they generate direct answers by synthesizing information from multiple sources. In an AI search, a user asks a question in natural language and the AI responds in kind, often without the need to click any external website. This shift is already altering search behavior and content strategies:
•Pre-trained Models vs. Real-Time Crawling:
AI systems like ChatGPT typically generate responses based on pre-trained knowledge—a snapshot of the web and other data sources up to a specific cutoff point. They “know” what they were trained on and use that information to generate answers. Traditional search engines, on the other hand, continuously crawl and update their index in real time. That said, many AI tools—including ChatGPT (with browsing enabled), Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude—also have models or modes that access live information from the web. To better understand this landscape, we like to split AI visibility into two categories:
1. Offline visibility: Refers to how well your brand shows up in the pre-trained knowledge of the model. This influences how often your brand is mentioned in standard (non-browsing) AI responses.
2.Online visibility: Refers to how often your brand appears in live-crawled content that the AI model can access in real time when generating an answer. Both forms of visibility matter. Offline visibility determines whether you’re part of the AI’s foundational knowledge, while online visibility allows you to influence current, dynamic answers, often through fresh content, optimized structure, and smart distribution.
•Answers Instead of Links: A classic Google search might show 10 blue links for “best marketing automation tools.” An AI search might give you a spoken or written answer: e.g. “The top marketing automation tools are X, Y, and Z, each with these features…” – all within the chat interface. The AI might cite or list sources in small print, but the user gets the answer without clicking through to each provider’s website.
•Different Citation and Credit: AI engines cite sources differently (if at all). Some AI chat tools provide reference links, but others may just give an answer sourced from many places. Your content could be used in an answer and the user might never realize it came from your site.
Example: A user searches on Google for “best marketing automation software” and gets a list of results (you’d better hope your blog post is #1). The same user asks ChatGPT the same question and gets a conversational answer like “Based on expert reviews, the best marketing automation tools include HubSpot, Marketo, and ActiveCampaign…” The AI’s response might mention those brands (possibly drawn from various articles or reviews) without the user visiting any single website.
The impact: This AI-driven approach dramatically reduces direct website traffic from search engines. Users get what they need in one go. Bain & Company found that about 80% of consumers now rely on these “zero-click” AI results for at least 40% of their searches, which has already reduced organic web traffic by an estimated 15–25%. In short, people are clicking fewer links because the answer is already served up. For businesses, that means it’s not enough to rank #1 on Google – you also need to be part of the answer when the AI responds.
3. AI Search Optimization vs. Traditional SEO: Key Differences
Given this new behavior, how you optimize for AI-driven search (let’s call it AI Search Optimization, or Generative Engine Optimization GEO) versus traditional SEO will differ. Both aim to make your brand visible when people search, but they target very different “gatekeepers.” Here are some key differences:
•Target Algorithms: Traditional SEO targets search engine algorithms (e.g. Google’s PageRank and hundreds of ranking factors) to earn a higher position in results. AI search optimization targets AI models and agents – you’re optimizing so that an AI (ChatGPT, Bard, Bing’s GPT-4, etc.) picks up your content as it constructs an answer. It’s the difference between impressing Google’s crawler vs. an AI’s knowledge model.
•Search Results vs. Answers: In SEO, success is a click: the user sees your snippet and clicks through to your site. In AI search, success is being included in the AI’s answer – even if the user never visits your site directly. Traditional SEO is about being the result; AI optimization is about being part of the result.
•Content Optimization Tactics: SEO often emphasizes keywords (ensuring your page text matches search queries) and backlink building for authority. GEO emphasizes context and clarity – providing well-structured, factual content that an AI trusts. For example, content that includes authoritative data points, concise explanations, and even FAQs or summaries is more likely to be picked up by an AI for a quick answer. AI models value content they can easily parse and verify. (Think structured lists, Q&As, definitions, and content with schema markup – more on that shortly.)
•Freshness and Indexing: Google will index a new page minutes or hours after you publish it. Many AI models won’t “see” that content until they are next trained or updated. If an AI’s knowledge cutoff was, say, mid-2024, content you published today might not influence its answers until it learns about it. Some AI search tools do have live web access (e.g. Bing’s AI can fetch current info), but generally there’s a lag. This means optimizing for A
I might also involve feeding your latest content into AI-accessible formats (e.g. submitting to tools, using APIs, or ensuring it’s on frequently crawled sources).
In short, traditional SEO focuses on ranking high in search engines, whereas AI search optimization focuses on being recognized and recommended by AI models . The end goal of both is visibility, but the methods and metrics differ. You can read our full 2025 ultimate visibility guide on how to optimize for generative AI.
4. Should Businesses Stop Doing Traditional SEO?
Absolutely not. Traditional SEO is still a cornerstone of discoverability – the majority of web traffic today still comes from search engines, and those engines aren’t disappearing overnight. Google alone processes trillions of searches per year, which means countless opportunities for users to find your website. As of early 2025, even with the surge in AI chat usage, Google and Bing remain primary drivers of traffic. In fact, recent data shows Google.com is still the most visited site in the world, with ChatGPT’s site traffic a fast-growing (3Billion monthly views just in September 2024 and pace only growing now in 2025) but fraction of Google’s.So don’t throw out your SEO playbook just yet. The Google traffic is declining and companies are noticing the effect also on their paid Google ads but remember that Google itself is a heavy hitter in the AI game. When we say that keep optimizing for Google, we are talking about both traditional SEO and Generative AI Optimization (GAIO/ Generative Engine Optimization GEO) that you should do.
That said, businesses need to expand their approach to include AI search optimization alongside SEO. It’s not an either/or scenario, but a both/and. You want to appear in both the traditional SERPs and in AI-generated answers. Think of GEO as riding shotgun with SEO: together they cover more ground. SEO + GEO = Full Digital Visibility. Rather than replacing SEO, Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) and Generative Search Optimization (GSO) complement it, ensuring your business appears in both ranked search results and AI-driven responses.
When to Use Traditional SEO:
•To capture intent-driven traffic from search engines. When users are actively searching (especially with clear intent like “buy X online” or “pricing for Y software”), a well-optimized page can rank and bring that visitor directly to you.
•To optimize your website’s content and conversions. Your product pages, blogs, landing pages – all still need SEO best practices so humans (and search bots) can find and navigate them easily.
•For long-term content value. Evergreen content that ranks on Google can keep pulling in traffic for months or years. This is classic inbound marketing via search – still a proven strategy.
When to Use AI Search Optimization (GEO/GSO):
•To ensure AI assistants recognize and recommend your brand. If someone asks an AI, “What’s the best CRM for small business?” you want your name in that answer. GEO techniques can help by getting your brand and key points into the AI’s knowledge base and preferred sources.
•To structure content so AI cites it. This means providing well-structured answers (e.g. a quick summary box or FAQ on your blog post that an AI might quote) and adding authoritative references. If your content cleanly answers common questions and backs them with data, an AI is more likely to use it.
•To track and improve AI visibility. Just as you monitor Google rankings, you should monitor how and when your brand pops up in AI-generated results. There are now tools to track AI search visibility (more on this below). If you find, for example, that a competitor is consistently mentioned by AI for queries in your domain and you are not, that’s a gap to address and market share to be conquered.
The bottom line: Keep doing SEO, but broaden your scope. In the same way mobile search didn’t kill desktop search (it just added another channel), AI search is adding a new dimension. Companies that take care of both will cover all bases – those that ignore AI search may find themselves invisible to a hugely growing segment of users.
Also consider the business implications. Traditional SEO is already a massive industry—estimated at $89 billion globally in 2024, and projected to grow to $144 billion by 2030. GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) isn’t replacing that spend—it’s emerging as a fast-growing, complementary segment.
Gartner predicts that by 2026, traditional search engine volume could drop by 25% as users shift toward AI chatbots, and by 2028, organic search traffic could decrease by over 50% as generative AI becomes mainstream. Sure, predictions should always be taken with a pinch of salt—no one has a crystal ball. But one thing is certain: the adoption of AI chats is accelerating by the minute.
And it’s not always happening in obvious ways. Even if users aren’t typing directly into ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude, they might still be engaging with AI-generated answers through apps, devices, or services powered by those same foundational models in the background.
That doesn’t mean SEO is dying—it just means the search landscape is expanding. The pie is getting a new slice, and that slice is powered by AI. The smartest companies are already investing in both slices.
According to Adobe, over 70% of marketing leaders are already experimenting with generative AI tools in their workflows, particularly for content creation and data analysis—areas closely tied to both traditional SEO and emerging AI search optimization strategies.¹ In practice, this often means repurposing 5–15% of SEO budgets toward GEO experiments—while continuing to strengthen their core SEO efforts.
5. How to Optimize for Both SEO and AI Search
To stay ahead, you’ll want to adjust your content strategy to serve two masters: the traditional search engines and the new AI answer engines. Fortunately, many SEO fundamentals still help with AI, but there are additional steps to take. Here’s how to optimize for both:
1.Structure Content for AI Models and Search Engines – Good structure is universal. Use clear headings and subheadings (H2s, H3s) and break up content with bullet points or numbered steps. This not only helps human readers scan, but also helps AI models parse your content. Consider adding FAQ sections, concise summaries, or “key takeaways” boxes in your articles. An AI is more likely to quote or cite text that is already in a neat, digestible format (e.g. a list of tips or a definition in bold). The easier you make it for an AI to grab the answer, the more likely your content will be featured.
2.Implement Schema Markup and AI-Friendly Metadata – Schema markup (structured data) is like secret sauce for helping algorithms understand the context of your content. Adding Schema.org markup for FAQs, How-tos, Organization info, Products, etc., can boost your chances in both regular and AI search. For example, FAQ schema on a page might make Google show those FAQs in search results and make it easy for an AI to identify Q&A pairs to learn from. Also pay attention to metadata that might not have mattered before: ensure your open graph and meta descriptions are clear (AI tools pulling URLs might use those), and even experiment with new meta tags that some AI crawlers might look for (as standards evolve). In short, speak the language of machines by structuring your data – it helps Google today and will help AI models ingest your content accurately.
3.Track AI Search Visibility – You can’t optimize what you don’t measure. Just as you track your Google rankings and organic traffic, start tracking how your brand appears in AI-generated answers. Regularly test prompts on ChatGPT, Bing, Bard, and emerging AI search tools to see if and how your content is mentioned. Better yet, use dedicated AI search tracking tools (for example, Superlines’ AI Search Tracker) that show where your content is being cited in AI outputs . This kind of report can be eye-opening: it will reveal queries where competitors are getting named by the AI but you aren’t . Those gaps are opportunities to create content or optimizations so you do get mentioned next time. Tracking AI visibility over time also lets you gauge the impact of your GEO efforts (e.g. “We updated our FAQ page and now ChatGPT is citing it for relevant questions!”).
4.Optimize Content for AI Queries and Intent – Start publishing content that specifically addresses the kinds of questions users are asking AI. This might differ slightly from your usual SEO keyword research. Think about conversational queries or complex questions that someone might pose to ChatGPT or a voice assistant. For instance, instead of just a blog titled “Benefits of CRM software,” you might create one titled “What’s the best CRM for a mid-sized e-commerce business?” or “How to choose a CRM in 2025” – phrased like a question someone might ask an AI. Within that content, answer the question directly and succinctly (so an AI can lift the answer), then elaborate. Focus on high-intent, informational queries. Additionally, aim to get your brand and content into AI-friendly sources. That includes being cited on Wikipedia pages, getting mentioned in industry reports or reputable blogs, or even publishing your own research with data. These are sources LLMs are likely to train on or reference. The more the AI sees your brand associated with authoritative information, the better your chances of appearing in answers.
Pro tip: Don’t neglect optimizing your existing content as well. You can update top-performing SEO pages to be more AI-friendly by adding a brief summary or Q&A section at the top. For example, start an article with a “In a nutshell” summary in 2-3 sentences – perfect for an AI to grab. Many companies are now doing content refreshes with AI in mind, not just Google.
SEO & AI Search Optimization Must Work Together
Traditional SEO isn’t dead – but businesses that only focus on Google rankings will miss out on a growing share of voice in search. To stay competitive in the age of AI, brands should combine their classic SEO tactics with AI search optimization (GEO) to maximize visibility across all platforms. Think of it like covering both search boxes: the one where users hit “enter” and the one where they ask an AI assistant.
The marketing leaders who master this balancing act stand to reap big rewards. Early movers in GEO are already seeing small but meaningful traffic streams from AI referrals – often highly qualified visitors who trust the AI’s recommendation. And as AI adoption in search skyrockets, those trickles could turn into streams. (By some estimates, chatbot-style search engines might drive one-third of all organic traffic for B2B sites within a few years !) In short, this isn’t about choosing SEO vs. AI. It’s about integrating AI into your SEO.
The future of search is hybrid. Companies that maintain their traditional SEO and optimize for generative AI will be the ones visible everywhere – whether a customer is scrolling Google at 8am, or asking Alexa or ChatGPT for advice at midnight. So, build your content strategy to win on both fronts. Your goal should be simple: when someone searches – on any platform, by typing or talking – your brand is there with the answer.
Curious how your brand is performing in AI-driven search? Make sure to start tracking and optimizing for these new generative platforms. With the right approach (and the right tools, like Superlines, to guide you), you can ensure that as search evolves, your marketing stays one step ahead.
Meta Title: Does AI Search Optimization Replace Traditional SEO? | GEO vs. Traditional SEO in 2025
Meta Description: AI-driven search is transforming how content is discovered – but will it make traditional SEO obsolete? This in-depth guide for marketers explores AI search optimization vs. SEO in 2025, showing how Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) works alongside classic SEO. Learn data-backed insights, real use cases, and practical tips to maximize your brand’s visibility in both Google and AI-generated answers.
Thank you for reading and as a next step, you can can start tracking what your visibility looks like now in AI Chats!
Sign up to Superlines from here!